Understanding IRA Strategies for Retirement
Often, high-net-worth clients have accumulated significant wealth on a tax-deferred basis in individual retirement accounts (IRAs) and employer-sponsored retirement plans. The tax deferral benefits of IRAs and employer-sponsored retirement plans were created to incentivize people to save for retirement. However, retirees eventually will have to pay the tax bill on these accounts. By educating yourself on these rules and strategies, you can help redefine your Golden Years—assisting in the management of retirement income and maintaining you and your family’s lifestyle.
IRAs can be classified into two basic categories:
Contributions to traditional IRAs can be fully deductible, partially deductible or non deductible. There are no income limits to contributing – everyone can contribute. However, the deductibility of your contribution will depend on your income level and whether you are an employer sponsored plan participant.
Contributions to Roth IRAs are non deductible or after tax. There are income limits on contributions, but not on conversions.
Roth IRAs must be held at least five years and at least until age 59½ to take tax-free and penalty-free withdrawals from earnings, but contributions can be withdrawn at any time.
In general, most qualified employer plans and IRAs are pre-tax money. If you have after-tax amounts in your traditional, SEP or SIMPLE IRA, you must, when taking a distribution, determine how much of the distribution is attributable to the after-tax amount. This is calculated using IRS Form 8606. The portion of the distribution that is non-taxable must be pro-rated with amounts that are taxable. For instance, if the individual contributed $2,000 in after-tax amounts and has a pretax balance of $8,000, a distribution of $5,000 would be pro-rated to include $1,000 after-tax and $4,000 in pretax assets. This pro-rata treatment must continue until all the after-tax amounts have been distributed.
To determine the portion of the distribution that is taxable, taxpayers must aggregate all of their traditional, SEP and SIMPLE IRA’s balances. This requirement applies even if the after-tax contribution was made to only one IRA.
Distributions to owners of IRAs prior to age 59½ are subject to a 10% early withdrawal penalty tax. However, distributions to IRA beneficiaries are not subject to the penalty tax regardless of the age of the beneficiary.
What to Know About Required Minimum Distributions
Required minimum distributions (RMDs) are amounts the federal government requires you to withdraw annually from certain retirement savings vehicles after you reach age 70½. This includes traditional IRAs, SEP-IRAs and SIMPLE IRAs. Employer-sponsored retirement plans that are subject to RMD rules include qualified defined contribution plans: 401(k) plans, Section 457(b) plans and Section 403(b) plans.
Although these RMDs are required, some individuals may not need the funds. Required minimum distributions have the effect of producing taxable income when withdrawn – driving the retiree into a higher tax bracket when stacked on top of other sources of retirement income. The RMDs may cause a taxpayer to pay higher Medicare Part B premiums as well as affect Social Security taxation. Many strategies can be leveraged to minimize RMDs, both for those who have already reached the RMD phase and for those still accumulating towards it.
Tax diversification is important in retirement, positioning assets that are tax-free, tax-deferred and taxable. By ensuring you have different buckets of money and paying attention to the associated tax brackets, you will be better able to manage your tax liability.
Owners of IRAs must begin distribution by April 1 of the year following the year the account owner reaches age 70½. This is true whether the IRA owner is working or not.
Participants in employer-sponsored retirement plans, such as 401(k) plans, can wait until the later of 70½ or when they stop working.
Exception: Participants who own 5% or more of the business must take their first required distribution at age 70½ regardless of whether they are still working or not.
Other than the first required distribution, which can be delayed to the April 1 deadline, all subsequent required distributions must be made by December 31 of the year.
The amount of the required distribution is determined by dividing the prior year-end account balance by the account owner’s life expectancy using the IRS Uniform Life Table.
If the sole beneficiary of the IRA is a spouse who is more than 10 years younger, the Joint Life and Last Survivor Expectancy table is used to calculate RMDs. IRA owners will not be required to withdraw as much money each year as you would if your spouse were older.
RMDs will increase each year on a percentage basis.
IRA owners or plan participants who fail to make the required distribution for a given year must correct the error and pay a 50% penalty tax.
RMDs must be taken from each employer-sponsored retirement plan. However, IRAs can be aggregated for RMD calculation purposes with the RMD only taken from one or less than all IRAs. This could permit the IRA owner to satisfy the RMDs from more liquid accounts and keep other IRAs fully invested for continued growth potential.
Strategies for Managing RMDs and Taxable Income
Roth IRA Conversions
If reducing RMDs is a top concern for you, you may want to consider a Roth conversion. This is because you are not required to take RMDs from your Roth IRA during your lifetime. While conversion is a taxable event, you can exchange a one-time tax hit for a lifetime of never having to worry about RMDs and their tax consequences. The conversion should be done while you are in a lower tax rate. In the future, with added Social Security distributions and other retirement income, your future tax rate may be higher. With a Roth conversion, the funds stay in a tax-free account and benefit from this for the rest of the owner’s and the surviving spouse’s lifetime. Keep in mind your non-spouse beneficiaries will need to take RMDs from the inherited Roth IRA. However, these distributions will most likely be tax-free.
Qualified Charitable Distribution
For clients who do not need the income from the required distribution, they could take advantage of the Qualified Charitable Distribution. Clients over age 70½ can distribute up to $100,000 each year directly from an IRA to qualified charities. The distribution can be used to satisfy the taxpayer’s RMD, and the distribution will not be added to the taxpayer’s taxable income.
Married couples can consider "re-contributing" an RMD back into a younger spouse’s IRA or employer retirement plan instead. The younger spouse must be eligible to contribute in the first place. The couple will receive a tax deduction that offsets the couple’s RMD obligation.
Take Excess Distributions from Accounts Already Subject to RMDs
If an RMD must come from some pre-tax retirement account, it is better to take the additional distribution from the same account that is already funding the RMDs. The idea is for a couple to keep as much of the younger spouse’s retirement account dollars in place as possible so that it can compound as long as possible and take retirement spending dollars from the account that is required to be liquidated by RMDs anyway. The excess distribution will further reduce the retirement account value and therefore the amount of the RMD in future years.
Upon turning 70½, it can make sense for some investors to use tax-deferred accounts for bonds and bond funds, and use taxable accounts for stock and stock funds. The advantage is that bonds and bond funds are taxed at ordinary income rates anyways, while stock and stock funds in a taxable account benefit from the reduced capital gains rate. Also, because bonds have historically underperformed stocks, it is likely that you will have fewer gains in bond-heavy retirement accounts. And because RMDS are based on the previous year-end value of your IRA account, an IRA account that grows more slowly will produce smaller RMDs.
Beneficiary distribution planning is just as important as distributions when the original IRA owner was alive. Please note not all beneficiary distribution options may be available in a qualified employer plan.
IRA Death Distribution Options
The beneficiary payout options for IRAs are affected by whether the deceased owner had reached the required beginning date for RMDs, and they generally fall into two broad rules.
The Five-Year Rule
This requires full distribution of the amount payable by December 31 of the fifth year following the account owner’s year of death. The five-year rule is not available to beneficiaries of accounts that had already begun required minimum distributions to the IRA owner. If an IRA owner dies before the required beginning date and the account beneficiary is an entity (a charity, an estate, a trust), the account must be paid out under the five-year rule.
The Exception for Qualified Trusts
Treasury regulations allow for one exception to this requirement — qualified trusts, also referred to as "look-through" or "see-through" trusts. When the entity beneficiary is a trust that meets the conditions below, the beneficiary account can be stretched by "looking through" the trust to the oldest beneficiary of the trust and making distributions based on that.
Requirements for Exemption
- Be a valid trust under state law
- Be irrevocable or, by its terms, become irrevocable upon the death of an IRA owner
- Have beneficiaries that are identifiable from the trust instrument and who are all individuals
- Have a trustee provide appropriate documentation to the IRA custodian
The Life Expectancy Rule (Stretch IRA, Beneficiary IRA, Decedent IRA)
This rule requires distribution of the amount payable over the life expectancy of the beneficiary. Distributions must begin by December 31 of the year following the year of death of the original account owner.
Timing is Critical
The surviving spouse beneficiary must begin distributions by December 31 of the year in which his or her deceased spouse would have attained age 70½. Prior to this point, the surviving spouse is not required to make distributions, although he or she may elect to do so at any time.
The beneficiary required distribution is determined by dividing the IRA balance on December 31 of the year preceding the year of distribution by the beneficiary’s life expectancy factor as determined through the IRS Single Life Table. Stretching the IRA allows the beneficiary to receive smaller distributions each year and stretch the tax liability over his or her lifetime. At any time, the beneficiary could accelerate the distributions, keeping in mind that the larger distributions will increase the tax he or she must pay.
If the IRA owner has died after the required beginning date, the decedent’s final RMD for his or her year of death must be distributed before beneficiaries can start to receive money from the account.
A spouse who is the beneficiary to his or her deceased spouse’s IRA has more options than does a non-spouse beneficiary. A surviving spouse can:
- Distribute the account under the five-year rule (if RMDs have not started)
- Rollover the account to an IRA in the surviving spouse’s name.
- Treat the IRA as a beneficiary account (stretch the IRA)
Spousal assumption is the most common option elected by surviving spouses. If the surviving spouse is named as the beneficiary to the decedent’s IRA, the surviving spouse may elect to treat the account as his or her own. In this case, the surviving spouse would take distributions from the account upon attaining age 70½ under the normal RMD rules. Note that distributions would not be required before that date, nor are they prohibited. The surviving spouse may elect this option at any time, even if he or she has previously treated the account as a stretch IRA and has taken distributions.
Stretching vs. Spousal Assumption
Stretching the IRA provides certain advantages depending on the age of the surviving spouse. If the surviving spouse is under age 59½, he or she might choose to stretch to avoid the 10% premature penalty on distributions. Later, the account could be switched to his or her personal IRA. During the period the account is held as a beneficiary account, no distributions would be required until the year in which the decedent would have reached age 70½. Once the surviving spouse elects to treat the account as their own, distributions would be required once the surviving spouse reaches age 70½. The surviving spouse’s ability to assume ownership can be exercised at any time. By correctly timing the use of beneficiary status and the assumption of ownership, the beneficiary spouse could avoid the 10% penalty for an extended period.
If the surviving spouse is over age 70½ and the decedent spouse was not, the surviving spouse could avoid RMDs by leaving the account in beneficiary status as distributions from the beneficiary account are not required until the decedent would have been 70½.
Getting On the Right Path
The right IRA strategy can set a course for your retirement. It is paramount to understand your options, the array of accounts you have available, and the right mix to make your golden years the brightest they can be.
About Gretchen Miller, MBA, CFP®
Gretchen offers her clients sophisticated financial planning advice and a comprehensive set of strategies to grow and preserve their wealth. Before recommending any course of action, Gretchen begins with a conversation that helps her understand your personal situation, current needs, and goals. She then helps to create and implement a unique financial plan, coordinating strategies with your attorneys and accountants and following up on a regular basis to ensure the plan is performing optimally.
Gretchen has more than 20 years of experience in financial services and is well qualified to help clients implement strategies to achieve their goals. Most recently, prior to joining Key, Gretchen served as Director of Advanced Planning for Prudential Financial, where she was a subject matter expert on financial and estate planning, and on retirement topics such as Social Security and Medicare.